Radhika Sainath in Inside Higher Ed: What Comes After the Macklemore Moment?

“A stream of federal court decisions dismissing [pro-Israel legal complaints], together with a new generation of students appalled by Israel’s ongoing genocide, is creating the conditions for a robust return of student activism,” writes our litigation director Radhika Sainath in a new op-ed in Inside Higher Ed.

“Behind [anti-Palestinian repression] is a legal strategy that goes back nearly two decades; a result of pro-Israel advocates (like Kraft) feeling that they were losing the narrative war on college campuses and shifting gears to make it a form of discrimination to advocate for Palestinian human rights.

This weaponizing of civil rights law has been failing. On campus, a steady stream of federal court decisions dismissing these antispeech (and racist) legal theories, together with a new generation of students appalled by Israel’s ongoing genocide, is creating the conditions for a robust return of student activism.

…Between Oct. 7, 2023, and November 2025, at least 26 lawsuits (and more than 100 complaints) claiming that universities were creating a hostile environment for Jewish students in violation of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act were filed. The lawsuits not only targeted speech critical of Israel and Zionism, but also argued that wearing Palestinian clothing or, in one case, hosting a festival celebrating Palestinian literature constituted actionable discrimination.

These lawsuits are now making their way through courts—with judge upon judge holding that speech critical of Israel or supportive of Palestinian rights is protected by the First Amendment and does not violate Title VI.”